Sweet, fresh and satisfying creations made right here at Lefty’s Cafe! Nothing is more satisfying than a slice of homemade pie! At Lefty’s Café, we love our pie. Whole pies are available by pre-ordering! ~HAVE IT YOUR WAY~ Warmed up, topped with ice cream, or topped with real whipped cream – the choice is yours!
Flapper A creamy vanilla custard pie on a graham crust topped with real whipped cream that is delicious and satisfying.
Cherry Sweet cherries baked in a golden crust.
Blueberry Blueberries bursting with flavour baked in a golden crust. Coconut Cream Sweetened toasted coconut baked in a homemade custard filling and topped with real whipped cream. This pie is comforting to the last bite!
Key Lime A creamy and tangy lime flavoured filling in a golden brown crust. Perfect for a hot day! Apple This classic old fashioned pie is made with tasty apples tossed in sugar and cinnamon and a few secret ingredients all baked in a beautiful brown crust.
Selection varies by day. Ask your server what pies are available today!
Lemon Meringue Sweet and tart at the same time, this pie is lemony good and is topped with fluffy meringue.
Rhubarb Cream Tender chunks of homegrown rhubarb mixed with delicious cream to make a deep dish custard pie full of flavour! An all-time Lefty’s Café favourite!
Chocolate Decedant rich and creamy chocolate filling topped with ridiculous amounts of real whipped cream!
Banana Cream Sweet ripe bananas nestled in a creamy banana custard topped with whipped cream. An all time favourite with young and old!
Pumpkin A sweet holiday favourite with just the perfect amount of pumpkin and spice.
Foothills Creamery Ice Cream
Premium ice cream made here in Alberta. ‘You simply can’t beat the taste', from Tiger, to Burgundy Cherry to Maple Nut, we have a variety of flavours that change regularly.